
Unforgettable
Melanie Harlow
Cloverleigh Farms #5
A disgraced MLB pitcher returns home for a wedding and rediscovers the girl he never forgot.
Description
Back then, I had it all.Wicked fastball. Killer instinct. Cocky grin. Full package. (And believe me, I knew how to score.)My senior year, I was a first round draft pick with a two-million-dollar signing bonus. Before I could even legally buy myself a beer, I made my Major League debut. Point is, I was invincible.Until one day I wasn’t.After tanking my career—during the World Series, no less—the last thing I want to do is return to my hometown, where every jerk in a ball cap has an opinion about what went wrong with my arm. So when my sister drags me back to town for her wedding, I vow to get in and out of there as quickly as possible. Then I run into April Sawyer.In high school we were just friends, but I’d always wanted her, and I’d never forgotten her—the red hair, the incredible smile, the crazy, reckless thing we did in the back of my truck the night we said goodbye. It’s been eighteen years, but one look at her and I feel like my old self again. I can still make her laugh, she can still take me down a notch, and when the chemistry between us explodes, it’s even hotter this time around—and I don’t want it to end.But just when I think I’m ready to let go of the past and get back in the game, life throws me a curveball I never saw coming.
Cloverleigh Farms series
Books like this

Pucking My Ex
Blakely Stone
A decade after their messy split, one Italian wedding, one wild night, and two pink lines change everything.
6 tropes in common

Squeeze Play (Richmond Rogues, #1)
Kate Angell
Her 'rebound guy' since high school is actually her one true love — but she's too scared to change their arrangement.
8 tropes in common

On a Tuesday
Whitney G.
He was the football star she fell for in college — until she vanished. Seven years later, it's Tuesday again.
8 tropes in common

Beauty and the Baller
Ilsa Madden-Mills
A grieving NFL star proposes fake dating to his small-town neighbor — not knowing she's the one-night stand he never for
9 tropes in common

Say You Swear
Meagan Brandy
She always imagined her future with him — until heartbreak shattered everything she thought she knew.
7 tropes in common

Dare You to Hate Me: A College Sports Romance
B. Celeste
The boy she left behind four years ago is now Lindon U's star tight end — and he refuses to let her go again.
9 tropes in common

Dearest Clementine (Dearest, #1)
Lex Martin
Three best friends, three love stories: a campus RA, a footballer's brother, and an NFL star walk into your TBR.
6 tropes in common

Enemies
Tijan
She's hated her NFL-star neighbor since sixth grade — but now he's the one trying to save her.
8 tropes in common

Hits Different: An MM Friends to Lovers Sports Romance
Joel Rustin
Three years after breaking his best friend's heart, Parker finally realises he's the one in love.
8 tropes in common

Homerun Proposal (Orleans University, #1)
Maren Moore
Her virginity proposal went to the wrong brother — her secret crush, the cocky baseball captain.
6 tropes in common

Her Greatest Mistake
Hannah Cowan
Hockey's golden boy must fake-date the childhood sweetheart who broke his heart — eight years too late.
7 tropes in common

Rookie Move
Sarina Bowen
Six years after she broke his heart, Georgia is now Leo's team publicist — and he just declared his feelings on a live m
7 tropes in common

The C*ck Down the Block
Amy Award
She asked her football star best friend to fake-date her at a reunion — he's been secretly in love for years.
6 tropes in common

Weak Side (Bexley U)
S.J. Sylvis
She ends up in the male dorms — and her cocky hockey roommate proposes they fake date to solve both their problems.
5 tropes in common

The Blueprint
S.E. Harmon
A gay man falls for his straight best friend — an NFL star who might feel more than he's willing to admit.
6 tropes in common

Flying
Jordana Blake
A wellness influencer returns to her small town — and the anxious best friend who never stopped loving her.
8 tropes in common

Cocky Mother Pucker: a fake dating college hockey romance
Sarah Smith
A cocky hockey captain fake-dates the genius who hates him — and tutors him — until feelings become very real.
5 tropes in common

The Secret of Ella and Micha (The Secret, #1)
Jessica Sorensen
She ran from home — and him — to bury her secrets, but Micha next door won't let her disappear again.
9 tropes in common

Line of Scrimmage
Marie Force
An NFL quarterback has ten days to win back the wife who's already walking out the door.
5 tropes in common

Behind the Net (Vancouver Storm, #1)
Stephanie Archer
Her high school crush is now her grumpy NHL boss — and her live-in roommate.
6 tropes in common




