
Homerun Proposal
Maren Moore
Orleans University #1
Her virginity proposal went to the wrong brother — her secret crush, the cocky baseball captain.
Description
The proposal was Score a homerun and take my virginity.Except, my proposal went to the wrong brother.It was supposed to go to my best friend, but as fate would have it, it fell into the hands of his infuriatingly hot, irritatingly charming older brother.Lane Collins is Orleans University's All-Star baseball captain.Cocky pitcher. Player on and off the field. The life of every party.And the same guy I’ve crushed on in secret since we were kids.He’s always been out of my league.That is until he signs the dotted line on a proposal that wasn’t meant for him, and offers to teach me… everything.The one and only condition?We walk away once everything’s checked off.Easier said than done when my heart is involved.Now, it’s a whole new ballgame.
Books like this

Dearest Clementine (Dearest, #1)
Lex Martin
Three best friends, three love stories: a campus RA, a footballer's brother, and an NFL star walk into your TBR.
11 tropes in common

Cocky Mother Pucker: a fake dating college hockey romance
Sarah Smith
A cocky hockey captain fake-dates the genius who hates him — and tutors him — until feelings become very real.
11 tropes in common

The Draft: A Brother's Best Friend College Hockey Romance
Ana Shay
She's his massage therapist, his best friend's sister, and the fake girlfriend who's making him forget it's pretend.
10 tropes in common

Jake Undone (Jake, #1)
Penelope Ward
A phobia-riddled nursing student falls hard for her tattooed genius roommate — who's hiding a life-changing secret.
7 tropes in common

#Nerd (Hashtag, #1)
Cambria Hebert
A nerdy scholarship girl and a star athlete are forced together — but falling in love breaks all the rules.
8 tropes in common

Weak Side (Bexley U)
S.J. Sylvis
She ends up in the male dorms — and her cocky hockey roommate proposes they fake date to solve both their problems.
9 tropes in common

Seducing Cinderella (Fighting for Love, #1)
Gina L. Maxwell
An MMA fighter offers seduction lessons to his best friend's nerdy little sister — but soon he's the one falling.
10 tropes in common

Power Plays & Straight A's
Eden Finley
A hockey player promised his brother he'd watch over the adorable nerd — not fall for him.
9 tropes in common

Pucking My Playboy Off-Limits Billionaire: Grumpy, Brother's Best Friend, Enemies To Lovers, Sports Romance
Amy Hunt
A free-spirited bookworm and her brother's grumpy hockey billionaire can't stop butting heads — or falling hard.
7 tropes in common

Teardrop Shot
Tijan
She got fired, he got a new roommate — and their NBA training camp friendship crosses every line.
8 tropes in common

After (After, #1)
Anna Todd
A good girl falls hard for a cruel, tattooed bad boy who keeps pushing her away — but can't let her go.
7 tropes in common

The C*ck Down the Block
Amy Award
She asked her football star best friend to fake-date her at a reunion — he's been secretly in love for years.
9 tropes in common

Bet in the Dark (In the Dark, #1)
Rachel Higginson
Framed for her roommate's poker debt, Ellie must work for the guy collecting it — and tries not to fall for him.
8 tropes in common

Tell Me You Want Me (College Romance, #1)
Amelia James
A bookworm who avoids fun + a bad boy who avoids feelings = chemistry they can't study away.
9 tropes in common

After Math (Off the Subject, #1)
Denise Grover Swank
A math-obsessed introvert tutors the campus's bad-boy soccer star — and discovers the secrets beneath his chaos.
7 tropes in common

The Unofficial Zack Warren Fan Club
J.C. Isabella
She started a secret fan club for him as a kid — now they're step-siblings and he's obsessed with her.
8 tropes in common

Infamous Park Avenue Prince
Ella Frank
A campus playboy bets he can corrupt the dean's straight, good-boy son — and loses himself in the game.
8 tropes in common

Pucked and Pregnant: Brother’s Best Friend Pretend Romance
Lila Blair
Her brother's best friend bullied her for her curves — now she's his fake fiancée and pregnant with his baby.
8 tropes in common

Fix Her Up
Tessa Bailey
The town clown and the washed-up baseball star fake date — and both forget it's supposed to be pretend.
8 tropes in common

Red Thorns
Rina Kent
The star quarterback made a bet on her — and now he's making her darkest fantasies come true.
9 tropes in common