
The One I Want
Chelle Sloan · Rolling Hills #1
A retired NFL player moves home after divorce — and falls hard for the nanny he definitely shouldn't want.
Description
As a professional football player, I had a playbook for everything on the field. Then I retired and found out there’s no playbook for life—especially when the one you thought was perfect gets flipped upside down. There’s no play for suddenly becoming a divorced, single dad. There’s no plan for moving your family back to the town you grew up in. And there is definitely not a play for falling in love with the nanny. I didn’t mean to. Betsy Sullivan just has that way about her. It started with wanting to see her smile. It grew to needing to hear her laugh. Before I knew it, her red lips and perfect curves were all I could think about. And I started to picture a life together - A perfect life together. Except nothing is ever perfect. Nothing is how you envision it. I learned that hard lesson once already. And if I’m not careful, I might find myself learning it again. I shouldn’t want her. My head knows that. My heart doesn’t seem to care. Neither does hers.
Books like this

Things We Never Got Over
Lucy Score · Knockemout #1
A grumpy barber reluctantly helps a stranded runaway bride — and the surprise niece she's now raising.
9 tropes in common

Funny Story
Emily Henry
Dumped by the same couple, two exes become roommates — then accidentally fall for each other.
6 tropes in common

Book Lovers
Emily Henry
A cutthroat literary agent escapes to a small town — only to keep running into the brooding editor she can't stand.
6 tropes in common

Reminders of Him
Colleen Hoover
Fresh out of prison, a mother risks everything when she falls for the one man standing between her and her daughter.
5 tropes in common

Happy Place
Emily Henry
Broken up for five months but still pretending to be together — for one last week at the cottage they both love.
7 tropes in common

It Ends with Us (It Ends with Us, #1)
Colleen Hoover · It Ends with Us #1
Lily falls for a brilliant surgeon who hides a dangerous side — and her first love just walked back in.
6 tropes in common

The Last Letter
Rebecca Yarros
A soldier fulfils his fallen best friend's dying wish — but falling for the sister was never part of the plan.
9 tropes in common

Beach Read
Emily Henry
A romance writer and a literary snob swap genres for the summer — and accidentally swap hearts too.
6 tropes in common

People We Meet on Vacation
Emily Henry
Ten summers, two best friends, and one truth that ruined everything — can one last trip fix them?
7 tropes in common

Blindside Beauty
Lex Martin · Varsity Dads
A accident-prone bookworm becomes nanny to her grumpy football-player neighbor's daughter — and his reluctant heart.
11 tropes in common

Red, White & Royal Blue
Casey McQuiston
The US President's son falls for the British prince they've been faking a friendship with — secretly, scandalously.
4 tropes in common

November 9
Colleen Hoover
They meet only on November 9th each year — but is their love story real, or just his novel's perfect plot twist?
4 tropes in common

Flawless
Elsie Silver · Chestnut Springs #1
A scandal-prone bull rider is forced to let his agent's sharp-tongued daughter babysit his reputation — and his heart.
9 tropes in common

Me Before You (Me Before You, #1)
Jojo Moyes · Me Before You #1
A quirky, warm-hearted carer takes a job with a bitter former adventurer — and changes both their lives forever.
3 tropes in common

It Happened One Summer
Tessa Bailey · Bellinger Sisters #1
A Beverly Hills party girl exiled to a small fishing town butts heads with a gruff, bearded sea captain.
8 tropes in common

The Time Traveler's Wife
Audrey Niffenegger · The Time Traveler's Wife #1
She's always known him, but he keeps vanishing through time — their love story told from both sides of the clock.
4 tropes in common

Archer's Voice (Pelion Lake, #1)
Mia Sheridan · Where Love Meets Destiny #1
A trauma-haunted woman finds healing in a small Maine town — and in the beautiful, silent man no one else can reach.
8 tropes in common

The House in the Cerulean Sea
T.J. Klune · Cerulean Chronicles #1
A rule-following caseworker investigates a magical orphanage — and falls for the man devoted to protecting it.
5 tropes in common

Twisted Love
Ana Huang · Twisted #1
Her brother's best friend is cold, ruthless, and hiding dangerous secrets — and completely obsessed with her.
6 tropes in common

Beauty and the Baller
Ilsa Madden-Mills · Strangers in Love #1
A grieving NFL star proposes fake dating to his small-town neighbor — not knowing she's the one-night stand he never for
11 tropes in common