
Smoke and Wishes
A.J. Macey · Best Wishes #1
A newly awakened supernatural starts college surrounded by six devoted guys — and a crew dead set on destroying her.
Description
What do you do when your whole life is a lie? Go to college... I just found out that I’m a supernatural and now I’m attending Redwood Supernatural University. With its magic and mix of beings from myth and legend, I’m definitely not in the human world anymore. But not everything is picture perfect. I have the Bitch Crew that are determined to get rid of me, a guy that’s hell-bent on teaching me a lesson, and my past haunting me in my dreams. It’s not all bad though; I have my quirky roommate Sadie and six guys who seem intent on keeping me around. I got this...hopefully. Book 1 of the Best Wishes Series The Best Wishes Series is a WhyChoose/Reverse Harem saga featuring MMFMMMM meaning there is M/M content, and the female main character doesn't have to choose between her love interests. This series contains references involving PTSD, sexual assault recollections, domestic violence, and other themes that some readers may find triggering.
Books like this

The Fairer Hex
Lidiya Foxglove · A Witch Among Warlocks #1
A girl with no magical training lands at an all-warlock academy — and slowly wins over four forbidden supernatural men.
10 tropes in common

Bride
Ali Hazelwood · Bride #1
A vampire bride surrenders herself to the enemy wolf Alpha — but she has her own secret agenda.
8 tropes in common

Seven Wishes
Serena Akeroyd · The Caelum Academy Trilogy #1
Raised in a cult, Eve survives one prison only to find herself hunted at a paranormal academy by her own fated mates.
11 tropes in common

Fate Hollow Academy: Term 1
Lyra Winters · Fate Hollow Academy #1
A rejected fox shifter finds refuge — and seven fated mates — at a deadly supernatural academy.
12 tropes in common

Born of Embers
Quinn Arthurs · Phoenix Rising #1
A girl with a hidden power enters a shifter world — and finds herself surrounded by five dangerously compelling men.
10 tropes in common

Academy of Six
A.K. Koonce · Origins of the Six #1
Fake-dating a brooding demon at a supernatural academy where failing your classes literally means death.
10 tropes in common

Void
Raven Kennedy · The Void Universe #1
A power-absorbing outcast must survive a supernatural academy where the most powerful boys want her destroyed.
9 tropes in common

Blindly Indicted
Katie May · Blindly #1
A blind girl with secret powers is thrown into a paranormal prison — and claimed by a group of deadly alpha inmates.
11 tropes in common

Obsession
K. Loraine · The Mate Games: War #1
A broken wolf rejected her fated mate — now he's back, and he's brought dangerous company.
9 tropes in common

Reckless Souls
K.C. Kean · Saints Academy #1
An orphan discovers hidden magic and must navigate a supernatural academy — and four dangerously tempting Elites.
10 tropes in common

Forged in Blood
Sadie Kincaid · Broken Bloodlines #1
A lonely orphan at a vampire university catches the eye of three ruthless commanders — and their ancient, dangerous sire
10 tropes in common

Lost
M. Sinclair · Silver Falls University #1
A sheltered bitten wolf arrives at a prestigious supernatural university — and five possessive alphas claim her as their
9 tropes in common

Savage Hope
K.C. Kean · The Savage Six #1
After a decade in captivity, she enters a supernatural academy with six dangerous men and one year to break a deadly cur
11 tropes in common

Tethered to the World
Stacey Brutger · Phantom Touched #1
A girl who can defy death escapes her abusive uncle — straight into a supernatural university with a broken pack of her
10 tropes in common

The Awakening
Caroline Peckham · Zodiac Academy #1
Twin changelings arrive at Zodiac Academy and become targets of four powerful, dangerously hot celestial heirs.
10 tropes in common

Alpha Bully
Renee Rose · Wolf Ridge High #1
A shifter alpha targets the new human girl for revenge — but obsession is a dangerous game.
8 tropes in common

Cruel Magic
Eva Chase · Royals of Villain Academy #1
A lost royal heir is dragged to Villain Academy — where the four brutally alluring scions want her broken.
9 tropes in common

Dead Until Dark (Sookie Stackhouse, #1)
Charlaine Harris · Sookie Stackhouse #1
A telepathic Southern waitress falls for a vampire in a small town with a very big body count.
4 tropes in common

Dark Horse
Kel Carpenter · A Demon's Guide to the Afterlife #1
A demon tasked with reforming three world-ending men discovers they might be the ones to break her.
10 tropes in common

Winter's Guardian
G. Bailey · Her Guardians #1
A college girl stumbles into a supernatural war — and the broody wolf assigned to protect her can't stand her.
10 tropes in common