Cover of Everything He Couldn't

Affiliate links — we may earn a small commission, at no extra cost to you. Learn more

Everything He Couldn't

Harlow James · Newberry Springs #2

404 pagescontemporary romance
(3k)Steamy

He loved his best friend's girl in secret — now his best friend is gone, and he's proposing marriage.

Content Warnings
death of loved onegrief

Description

One of my favorite songs growing up was Jessie’s Girl by Rick Springfield. Ironically enough, I never realized I’d be living out those lyrics in my own life when I fell for my best friend’s girl—and then my best friend, John Schmitt, died.Add on the fact that she was pregnant with his child and that I’d been harboring feelings for Evelyn months before all of this happened, and well, now?Now the lyrics to that song don’t sound so bad anymore.The worst part is, I’m the one to blame for his death which made facing her an even harder pill to swallow, so what did I do? Pretend like she didn’t exist anymore, even though it was virtually impossible because she was everywhere in our small town of Newberry Springs.Flashforward six months and suddenly Evelyn finds herself in a legal battle she never saw coming, and I can’t just stand by any longer and pretend like my heart isn’t in shambles.So I suggest the unthinkable.I offer to marry her, help her prove that she’s a fit mother and her daughter is being raised well despite John not being in the picture.But Evelyn doesn’t know that being near her gets my blood pumping, even more so after avoiding her for months. She doesn’t understand that doing this favor for her is a way for me to gain retribution for John’s death and take a chance to find out if she can reciprocate my feelings.And she doesn’t get that by being there for her and loving her and her daughter that I’m doing everything that my best friend couldn’t.

Newberry Springs series

Books like this

Cover of Happy Place

Happy Place

Emily Henry

388 pagescontemporary romance
(1.5M)Steamy

Broken up for five months but still pretending to be together — for one last week at the cottage they both love.

8 tropes in common

Cover of Things We Never Got Over

Things We Never Got Over

Lucy Score · Knockemout #1

572 pagescontemporary romance
(1.1M)Steamy

A grumpy barber reluctantly helps a stranded runaway bride — and the surprise niece she's now raising.

8 tropes in common

Cover of Reminders of Him

Reminders of Him

Colleen Hoover

336 pagescontemporary romance
(1.7M)Steamy

Fresh out of prison, a mother risks everything when she falls for the one man standing between her and her daughter.

7 tropes in common

Cover of Funny Story

Funny Story

Emily Henry

416 pagescontemporary romance
(1.3M)Steamy

Dumped by the same couple, two exes become roommates — then accidentally fall for each other.

5 tropes in common

Cover of It Ends with Us (It Ends with Us, #1)

It Ends with Us (It Ends with Us, #1)

Colleen Hoover · It Ends with Us #1

352 pagescontemporary romance
(4.7M)Steamy

Lily falls for a brilliant surgeon who hides a dangerous side — and her first love just walked back in.

7 tropes in common

Cover of People We Meet on Vacation

People We Meet on Vacation

Emily Henry

382 pagescontemporary romance
(1.8M)Warm

Ten summers, two best friends, and one truth that ruined everything — can one last trip fix them?

7 tropes in common

Cover of Book Lovers

Book Lovers

Emily Henry

338 pagescontemporary romance
(1.6M)Steamy

A cutthroat literary agent escapes to a small town — only to keep running into the brooding editor she can't stand.

5 tropes in common

Cover of The House in the Cerulean Sea

The House in the Cerulean Sea

T.J. Klune · Cerulean Chronicles #1

400 pagescontemporary romance
(1.0M)Mild

A rule-following caseworker investigates a magical orphanage — and falls for the man devoted to protecting it.

7 tropes in common

Cover of The Last Letter

The Last Letter

Rebecca Yarros

426 pagescontemporary romance
(551k)Steamy

A soldier fulfils his fallen best friend's dying wish — but falling for the sister was never part of the plan.

10 tropes in common

Cover of The Time Traveler's Wife

The Time Traveler's Wife

Audrey Niffenegger · The Time Traveler's Wife #1

546 pagescontemporary romance
(1.9M)Steamy

She's always known him, but he keeps vanishing through time — their love story told from both sides of the clock.

6 tropes in common

Cover of Wait for It

Wait for It

Mariana Zapata

670 pagescontemporary romance
(116k)Steamy

A woman raising her nephews after tragedy slowly falls for the quiet, steady man next door.

11 tropes in common

Cover of Beach Read

Beach Read

Emily Henry

400 pagescontemporary romance
(1.7M)Steamy

A romance writer and a literary snob swap genres for the summer — and accidentally swap hearts too.

5 tropes in common

Cover of Red, White & Royal Blue

Red, White & Royal Blue

Casey McQuiston

448 pagescontemporary romance
(1.2M)Steamy

The US President's son falls for the British prince they've been faking a friendship with — secretly, scandalously.

4 tropes in common

Cover of November 9

November 9

Colleen Hoover

320 pagescontemporary romance
(1.3M)Steamy

They meet only on November 9th each year — but is their love story real, or just his novel's perfect plot twist?

4 tropes in common

Cover of Twisted Love

Twisted Love

Ana Huang · Twisted #1

343 pagescontemporary romance
(1.7M)Scorching

Her brother's best friend is cold, ruthless, and hiding dangerous secrets — and completely obsessed with her.

7 tropes in common

Cover of Somewhere You Belong

Somewhere You Belong

Harlow James · Carrington Cove #1

365 pagescontemporary romance
(4k)Steamy

She inherited his dream beach house. He wants it back. Neither planned on wanting each other.

6 tropes in common

Cover of Say You'll Remember Me

Say You'll Remember Me

Abby Jimenez · Say You'll Remember Me #1

416 pagescontemporary romance
(541k)Steamy

One perfect date, then she begs him to forget her — but some people are impossible to leave behind.

8 tropes in common

Cover of Me Before You (Me Before You, #1)

Me Before You (Me Before You, #1)

Jojo Moyes · Me Before You #1

385 pagescontemporary romance
(1.8M)Warm

A quirky, warm-hearted carer takes a job with a bitter former adventurer — and changes both their lives forever.

3 tropes in common

Cover of Love and Other Words

Love and Other Words

Christina Lauren

432 pagescontemporary romance
(834k)Warm

A decade of silence, one chance reunion, and the first love she never stopped carrying.

7 tropes in common

Cover of Out on a Limb

Out on a Limb

Hannah Bonam-Young · Out #1

397 pagescontemporary romance
(190k)Steamy

One night, one surprise pregnancy, and two strangers trying to become friends — then maybe something more.

7 tropes in common

A work in progress, built for my wife with love. Suggestions welcome