
The Initiation
L.J. Smith
The Secret Circle #1
A girl joins her hometown's witch coven — and falls for the one boy she absolutely cannot have.
Description
Cassie is initiated into her hometown's coven of witches but her love for the coven leader's boyfriend could prove deadly.
Books like this

Pants on Fire
Meg Cabot
Katie's perfect life starts unravelling when the boy she helped run out of town four years ago comes back.
4 tropes in common

Night World, No. 1 (Night World, #1-3)
L.J. Smith
In a secret world of vampires and witches, falling in love is the most dangerous rule you can break.
7 tropes in common

Hope's Chance
Jennifer Foor
A one-night stand turns complicated when she moves into her dad's mansion — and he's living in the pool house.
8 tropes in common

Vampire Academy (Vampire Academy, #1)
Richelle Mead
A half-vampire bodyguard returns to a deadly academy where the forbidden attraction to her instructor might kill her fir
6 tropes in common

Terra Feliz: Vanity
Ginny Bryce
Married to a stranger, Madeleine finds forbidden love on a remote island — but danger closes in from all sides.
7 tropes in common

Leaving Paradise (Leaving Paradise, #1)
Simone Elkeles
He hit her with his car. She put him in prison. Now they're back in the same small town and falling in love.
6 tropes in common

The Awakening (The Vampire Diaries, #1)
L.J. Smith
The most popular girl in school falls for the mysterious new boy — who happens to be a vampire hiding a deadly secret.
7 tropes in common

Existence (Existence, #1)
Abbi Glines
A girl who sees souls falls for a dangerously beautiful stranger — who turns out to be Death himself.
7 tropes in common

Chain of Gold
Cassandra Clare
A Shadowhunter girl secretly loves her childhood friend — who is promised to another — as demons tear London apart.
5 tropes in common

The Dark Divine (The Dark Divine, #1)
Bree Despain
Her childhood friend returns with a dark secret — and Grace's small-town world will never be the same.
6 tropes in common

Falling Under (Falling Under, #1)
Gwen Hayes
A sheltered girl is drawn to the dangerous boy from her dreams — who may be the cost of her soul.
6 tropes in common

Find Me: YA Paranormal Romantic Suspense
Francesca Riley
A girl returns to the shore where her mother drowned and falls for the cursed, mysterious swimmer who lives in the sea.
6 tropes in common

The Corruption of Hollis Brown
K. Ancrum
A ghost possesses a restless boy's body — and neither of them expected to fall in love.
5 tropes in common

My Life with the Walter Boys
Ali Novak
A prim NYC girl moves to a Colorado ranch and into a house full of twelve Walter boys.
3 tropes in common

The Unbecoming of Mara Dyer (Mara Dyer, #1)
Michelle Hodkin
A girl with no memory of the accident that killed her friends starts seeing corpses — and falling for the boy who believ
5 tropes in common

The Awakening / The Struggle (The Vampire Diaries, #1-2)
L.J. Smith
Elena wants the mysterious new boy — but he's a vampire, and his dangerous brother wants her for himself.
6 tropes in common

Slow Heat in Heaven
Sandra Brown
A prodigal daughter returns to her Louisiana hometown and can't resist the dangerous bad boy she should never want.
8 tropes in common

Bourbon & Lies (The Bourbon Boys #1)
Victoria Wilder
A grumpy ex-cop and the lying stranger hiding at his Kentucky distillery can't stay away from each other.
8 tropes in common

The Assassin and the Empire
Sarah J. Maas
Assassin Celaena and Sam risk one final mission to buy their freedom — but freedom has a devastating price.
4 tropes in common

Entangled with the Grumpy Firefighter: A Small Town Brother's Best Friend Romance
Amelia Belle
She returns to her small town only to be rescued from a fire by her brother's brooding best friend — then forced to nurs
7 tropes in common