Eternal Starling
Angela Corbett
Emblem of Eternity #1
Two men claim to be her eternal soul mate — but only one is telling the truth, and both want her soul.
Description
A love so strong, even eternity can't separate them. Evie Starling has lived a relatively uneventful life hanging out with friends, gossiping about boys, and driving her 1966 Mustang. All of that changes when she moves to Gunnison, Colorado, to start college and meets two mysterious men. For centuries, Alex Night and Emil Stone have yearned for Evie, but they each have their own reasons for wanting to be with her. When both men claim to be her soul mate and tell her about an unbelievable past, Evie learns that she's not the person she thought she was. Soon, Evie finds herself in the middle of an age-old battle between the Amaranthine Society the soul protectors, and the Daevos Resistance the soul destroyers. With a past she doesn't understand, and a future rife with danger, Evie has to decide who she can trust. But Alex and Emil aren't the only ones who want Evie, and her soul is about to become the rope in an eternal tug-of-war.
Books like this
Wildalone (Wildalone Sagas, #1)
Krassi Zourkova
A Princeton freshman falls into a mythic love triangle with two brothers hiding supernatural secrets.
7 tropes in common
A Demon's Promise
Kristie Cook
She wants normal; he hides dark secrets — but legend says their souls were made for each other.
7 tropes in common
The Bone Gatherer
Jennifer Adele
A broke college grad takes a job at a haunted estate — and falls for its dangerously secretive caretaker.
6 tropes in common
Pieces of Lies (Pieces of Lies, #1)
Angela Richardson
Banished to a new campus, Norah falls for a secret society's elusive leader — but love here is built on lies.
7 tropes in common
Harrow Faire Series
Kathryn Ann Kingsley
Trapped inside a sinister circus, a bank teller becomes the prize in a deadly war between two dark men.
5 tropes in common
Existence (Existence, #1)
Abbi Glines
A girl who sees souls falls for a dangerously beautiful stranger — who turns out to be Death himself.
8 tropes in common
Providence (Providence, #1)
Jamie McGuire
A mysterious guardian angel was born to protect her — but Hell wants her for something far darker.
7 tropes in common
This Blood that Binds Us
S.L. Cokeley
The vampire who nearly killed her goes to her university — and now they must hunt her attacker together.
5 tropes in common
The Kiss of Deception
Mary E. Pearson
A runaway princess falls for two strangers — not knowing one is her jilted prince and the other her assassin.
7 tropes in common
Tor
Lauren Esker
A heartbroken woman stumbles into a magical shifter town — and the arms of a very protective polar bear.
4 tropes in common
Ebo
L. Lombard
A woman chasing answers about her parents' deaths in Africa discovers she's being followed — by a man who remembers ever
6 tropes in common
Storm
Brigid Kemmerer
A girl who saves a boy who controls water discovers his power — and her secret — could get them both killed.
6 tropes in common
Seeing Red (Seeing Red, #1)
Sidney Halston
A psychic law student reunites with the twin boys she survived on a deserted island with — now grown, gorgeous, and both
7 tropes in common
Eternal Eden (Eden Trilogy, #1)
Nicole Williams
A normal college girl falls for a dangerously magnetic stranger whose world will change everything.
7 tropes in common
Insatiable (Insatiable, #1)
Meg Cabot
A soap writer who predicts deaths falls for a vampire — then a vampire hunter wants her help catching him.
5 tropes in common
Forest of the Forbidden
W.J. May
Six paranormal romance novellas: vampires, werewolves, magic, and the heroes who are dangerously hard to resist.
6 tropes in common
Strength (Mark of Nexus, #1)
Carrie Butler
She wants him, but his supernatural strength means one touch could kill her.
6 tropes in common
The No-Girlfriend Rule
Christen Randall
A girl joins a tabletop RPG group to save her boyfriend — and falls for the charismatic bard instead.
4 tropes in common
The Host (The Host, #1)
Stephenie Meyer
An alien soul inhabits a human body — and falls for the man her host's memories love.
6 tropes in common
A Little Too Far (A Little Too Far, #1)
Lisa Desrochers
She slept with her stepbrother, then fell for a priest-in-training in Rome. Both are off limits.
7 tropes in common